Chemistry 化学

Precipitation Reaction Discussion Examples | Relationship Between the Solubility Product and Precipitate Formation

Precipitation reactions are reactions in which ions in solution react to form solids that are poorly soluble in water.
In basic chemistry, analytical chemistry, and inorganic chemistry experiments at universities, they are commonly used for identification of cations and anions, qualitative analysis, gravimetric analysis, precipitation titration, and similar purposes.

In a precipitation-reaction report, it is not sufficient simply to write that “a precipitate formed” or “the solution became cloudy.”
It is important to explain why the precipitate formed, which combination of ions produced the sparingly soluble compound, and how the result can be explained from the relationship between the solubility product and the ionic product.
If no precipitate formed or the amount was smaller than expected, the result can also be discussed in terms of concentration, pH, the common-ion effect, complex formation, temperature, and other factors.

This article clearly explains how to interpret precipitation-reaction results, the relationship between the solubility product and precipitate formation, the conditions under which precipitation occurs, sources of error, points for improvement, and discussion examples that can be used in reports.

Note:
This article is a reference intended to assist with discussions of results obtained in chemistry experiments at universities and similar institutions.
For the actual handling of reagents, precipitation conditions, filtration, washing, waste-liquid disposal, and safety precautions, always follow the instructions in your university’s laboratory manual and those given by your instructor or TA.

What Is a Precipitation Reaction?

A precipitation reaction is a reaction in which ions in solution react to form a compound that is poorly soluble in water and appears as a solid.
The solid that forms is called a precipitate.
Precipitates may show various colors such as white, yellow, brown, and black.

For example, when a cation and an anion react to form a sparingly soluble salt, the solution may become cloudy or a solid may settle at the bottom.
This phenomenon can be used to determine whether a specific ion is present in a sample.

Cation + Anion → Sparingly Soluble Precipitate

Example Discussion:
When a precipitating reagent was added to the sample solution, a white precipitate formed.
This is considered to have occurred because the target ion in the solution reacted with an ion in the precipitating reagent to form a compound with low solubility in water.
Formation of the precipitate is a result suggesting that the target ion may be present in the sample.

Results to Examine in a Precipitation Reaction

In precipitation-reaction results, record not only whether a precipitate formed but also its color, amount, formation rate, turbidity of the solution, and solubility of the precipitate.
These observations provide information for discussing the type and concentration of ions and the reaction conditions.

Main Items to Include in the Results

  • Color and transparency of the sample solution
  • Type of precipitating reagent added
  • Presence or absence of precipitate
  • Color of the precipitate
  • Amount of precipitate
  • Whether the precipitate formed immediately or after some time
  • Condition of the supernatant
  • Whether the precipitate dissolves in acid, base, or excess reagent
  • Expected chemical formula of the precipitate
  • Comparison with theoretical precipitation conditions

Example of How to Write the Results:
When a precipitating reagent was added to the sample solution, a white precipitate formed immediately.
After the mixture was allowed to stand for a while, the precipitate settled at the bottom and the supernatant became almost clear.
From this, the target ion in the sample and the ion in the precipitating reagent are considered to have reacted and formed a sparingly soluble precipitate.

What Is the Solubility Product?

The solubility product is a value representing the product of ion concentrations in solution when a sparingly soluble salt is slightly dissolved in water and has reached equilibrium.
It is commonly written as Ksp and is an important indicator for determining whether a precipitate will form.

For example, when the sparingly soluble salt AB dissolves in water and separates into A+ and B−, the solubility product is expressed as follows.

Ksp = [A+][B−]

In practice, the exponents change depending on the chemical formula of the precipitate.
For a salt such as A2B, for example, the equation is written to reflect the stoichiometric relationship among the ion concentrations.
In a report, follow the dissolution-equilibrium equation for the precipitate specified in the laboratory manual.

Example Discussion:
Formation of a sparingly soluble salt precipitate can be explained by the relationship between ion concentrations in the solution and the solubility product.
When the product of the ion concentrations in solution exceeds the solubility product, the portion that cannot remain dissolved precipitates as a solid.
Therefore, whether a precipitate forms depends not simply on whether a reagent was added, but on the relative magnitudes of the ion concentrations and the solubility product.

What Is the Ionic Product?

The ionic product is the product of the ion concentrations in solution at a given moment.
Whereas the solubility product is the value at equilibrium, the ionic product is calculated from the actual concentrations immediately after mixing or during the reaction.
The ionic product is sometimes represented by Q.

Whether precipitation occurs is determined by comparing the ionic product Q with the solubility product Ksp.

Relationship State What Happens
Q < Ksp Unsaturated Precipitation is unlikely
Q = Ksp Saturated / equilibrium Dissolution and precipitation are balanced
Q > Ksp Supersaturated A precipitate forms

Example Discussion:
Adding the precipitating reagent increased the product of the concentrations of the target ion and the precipitating-reagent ion in the solution.
Because this ionic product exceeded the solubility product, the portion that could no longer remain dissolved precipitated as a solid.
Conversely, if the ionic product is smaller than the solubility product, precipitation is unlikely to occur.

Conditions for Precipitate Formation

A precipitate forms when the ionic product in solution exceeds the solubility product.
When a precipitating reagent is added, the concentration of one of the ions constituting the precipitate increases and the ionic product becomes larger.
As a result, precipitation begins when Ksp is exceeded.

However, even under conditions where precipitation is theoretically expected, the precipitate may be difficult to observe because the particles are too fine, the reaction is slow, or the concentration is low.

Example Discussion:
The precipitate is considered to have formed because the addition of the precipitating reagent caused the ionic product in solution to exceed the solubility product.
For precipitation to occur, the concentrations of the target ion and the precipitating-reagent ion must be sufficiently high.
Therefore, if the sample concentration or precipitating-reagent concentration is low, the ionic product may not exceed the solubility product and the precipitate may be difficult to observe.

Discussion When No Precipitate Forms

If no precipitate forms, this does not necessarily mean that the target ion is absent.
Possible causes include low ion concentration, insufficient precipitating reagent, inappropriate pH conditions, or a decrease in the free-ion concentration because of complex formation.

In particular, even when the target ion is present in the solution, the precipitation reaction may proceed poorly if the ion is not present as a free ion.

Example Discussion:
One possible reason the expected precipitate did not form is that the ionic product in the solution did not exceed the solubility product.
If the concentration of the target ion in the sample was low or the amount of precipitating reagent added was insufficient, the ionic product would not become sufficiently large.
In addition, if the target ion was present as a complex, the concentration of free metal ions would decrease, possibly making precipitation more difficult.

The Common-Ion Effect and Precipitate Formation

The common-ion effect is the phenomenon in which the solubility of a sparingly soluble salt decreases when an ion identical to one involved in its dissolution equilibrium is added from an external source.
Adding a common ion increases the ion concentration in solution, causing the equilibrium to shift more readily toward precipitate formation.

Therefore, when it is desirable to form the precipitate more completely, the precipitating reagent may be added in slight excess.
However, if too much is added, other reactions such as complex formation may occur, so caution is required.

Example Discussion:
When an excess of precipitating reagent is added, the concentration of the common ion constituting the precipitate increases.
As a result, the dissolution equilibrium shifts toward precipitate formation and the solubility of the precipitate decreases.
Through this common-ion effect, the target ion can be recovered more completely as a precipitate.
However, if the excess reagent causes complex formation, the precipitate may redissolve.

Effect of pH on Precipitation Reactions

Precipitation reactions may be strongly affected by pH.
In particular, for precipitation of metal hydroxides, increasing the pH increases the hydroxide-ion concentration and makes precipitation more likely.
Under acidic conditions, on the other hand, the hydroxide-ion concentration is low and precipitation may be less likely.

In sulfide and carbonate precipitation as well, pH changes the concentration or form of the precipitating ion and therefore changes the ease of precipitation.
In a report, it is useful to discuss the presence or absence of a precipitate in relation to the pH conditions.

Example Discussion:
In precipitation of metal hydroxides, the hydroxide-ion concentration increases as pH rises, making it easier for the ionic product to exceed the solubility product.
Therefore, precipitation occurs more readily under basic conditions.
Under acidic conditions, the hydroxide-ion concentration is low and the ionic product is less likely to exceed the solubility product, so precipitation is considered less likely to occur.

Suppression of Precipitation by Complex Formation

When metal ions form complexes with ammonia, chloride ions, cyanide-type ligands, EDTA, or similar species, the concentration of free metal ions in solution decreases.
When the free metal-ion concentration decreases, the ionic product required to form a precipitate also decreases, making precipitation more difficult.

A precipitate that has already formed may also dissolve because an excess ligand forms a soluble complex.
This phenomenon can be discussed as an example of competition between precipitation and complex formation.

Example Discussion:
One possible reason the amount of precipitate was smaller than expected is that the metal ions formed complexes with ligands.
When complex formation lowers the concentration of free metal ions, the ionic product of the ions constituting the precipitate decreases and is less likely to exceed the solubility product.
As a result, precipitate formation is considered to have been suppressed.

When a Precipitate Dissolves in Excess Reagent

In some cases, adding a small amount of a reagent forms a precipitate, while adding the same reagent in excess causes the precipitate to dissolve.
This occurs because the excess reagent forms a soluble complex or because an amphoteric hydroxide dissolves in excess acid or base.

In such a case, not only the precipitation reaction but also complex formation and acid-base reactions must be considered at the same time.

Example Discussion:
A precipitate formed when a small amount of reagent was added, but dissolved when the reagent was added in excess.
One possible reason is that the excess ligand formed a soluble complex with the metal ion and lowered the concentration of free metal ions in solution.
When the free metal-ion concentration decreases, the dissolution equilibrium of the precipitate shifts toward dissolution, explaining why the precipitate dissolved.

Relationship Between Precipitate Color and Chemical Species

The color of a precipitate provides a clue for estimating the chemical species formed.
However, many precipitates show similar colors, so the substance cannot be completely identified from color alone.
Precipitate color may change depending on the type of metal ion, oxidation state, particle size, contamination by impurities, and coexisting ions.

Example Discussion:
The color of the precipitate provides a clue for estimating the type of sparingly soluble compound formed.
However, because some ions produce precipitates with similar colors, the type of precipitate cannot be determined from color alone.
Therefore, the result must be judged together with the solubility of the precipitate, formation conditions, and confirmation-reaction results.

Discussion When the Amount of Precipitate Is Small

When the amount of precipitate is small, possible causes include a low concentration of the target ion in the sample, insufficient precipitating reagent, incomplete precipitation, partial dissolution of the precipitate, or suppression of precipitation by complex formation.
A small amount of precipitate does not necessarily mean that the target ion is absent.

Example Discussion:
One possible reason the amount of precipitate was small is that the concentration of the target ion in the sample was low.
In addition, if the amount of precipitating reagent added was insufficient, the ionic product would not become sufficiently large and precipitation would remain incomplete.
Furthermore, complex formation or partial dissolution of the precipitate may also reduce the amount of precipitate observed.

When Precipitation Occurs After a Delay

A precipitate may form immediately after reagent addition or may appear only after some time has passed.
Possible reasons for delayed precipitation include delayed nucleation from a supersaturated state, a slow reaction rate, temperature changes, or insufficient stirring.

Example Discussion:
One possible reason the precipitate formed after some time rather than immediately after reagent addition is that nucleation of the solid required time.
Even when the ionic product exceeds the solubility product, the precipitate may not become visible until solid-particle nuclei have formed.
In addition, insufficient stirring may have prevented the solution from becoming uniform, delaying precipitate formation.

Effect of Temperature on Precipitation Reactions

Solubility may change with temperature.
In some cases a precipitate becomes more soluble as the temperature rises, while in others the effect of temperature is small.
In experiments, heating or cooling may change the amount of precipitate formed or the size of the crystals.

Because the effect of temperature differs depending on the type of precipitate, discussion should be based on the laboratory manual and the observed results.

Example Discussion:
One possible reason the amount of precipitate differed from the expected value is a change in solubility caused by temperature.
Even sparingly soluble salts may show changes in solubility with temperature, and under higher-temperature conditions some precipitate may remain dissolved in the solution more readily.
As a result, the amount of precipitate recovered is considered to have decreased.

Effects of Insufficient Stirring

In precipitation reactions, it is important that the sample solution and precipitating reagent mix uniformly.
If stirring is insufficient, regions of locally high or low concentration may form and precipitation may become uneven.
As a result, precipitate particles may become fine or locally excessive precipitation may occur.

Example Discussion:
If stirring was insufficient, the precipitating reagent would not spread uniformly throughout the solution, producing regions with locally high ion concentrations.
As a result, the precipitate could form unevenly, causing variation in particle size and amount.
To perform precipitation reactions with higher reproducibility, it is important to stir sufficiently after adding the reagent.

Discussion of Precipitate Particle Size

If precipitate particles are fine, they are difficult to filter and may pass through the filter paper or be washed away during washing.
In addition, because fine particles have a large surface area, they more readily adsorb impurities.
In contrast, larger crystalline precipitates may be easier to filter and wash.

Example Discussion:
If the precipitate particles were fine, part of the precipitate may have been lost during filtration or washing.
Therefore, in experiments where the precipitate amount is treated quantitatively, the recovered amount may become smaller than the actual amount formed.
In addition, because fine precipitates have a large surface area and readily adsorb impurities, the purity of the precipitate may also be affected.

Errors Caused by Coprecipitation

Coprecipitation is a phenomenon in which components that should not normally precipitate are incorporated together when the target precipitate forms.
When coprecipitation occurs, errors arise in the mass and composition of the precipitate.
It is an especially important source of error in gravimetric analysis and quantitative precipitation reactions.

Example Discussion:
One possible reason impurities were present in the precipitate is that coprecipitation occurred.
If other ions in solution are incorporated into the precipitate during its formation, the mass of the precipitate becomes larger than the mass of the target compound alone.
Therefore, when the precipitate is used for quantitative analysis, coprecipitation may cause the result to be overestimated.

Errors Caused by Insufficient Washing

Mother liquor and soluble impurities may adhere to a precipitate.
If the precipitate is dried and weighed without sufficient washing, components other than the precipitate are also included in the mass.
Even when the precipitate is used for a confirmation reaction, residual reagents or ions may affect the next reaction.

Example Discussion:
If the precipitate was insufficiently washed, mother liquor and soluble impurities would remain on the precipitate surface.
As a result, in an experiment measuring precipitate mass, components other than the target precipitate would also be included and the mass could become too large.
In addition, in confirmation reactions, residual ions or reagents may affect the reaction and cause misidentification.

Errors Caused by Excessive Washing

Washing is necessary to remove impurities, but if washing is excessive, part of the precipitate may dissolve in the washing solution or fine precipitate particles may be washed away.
In this case, the amount of precipitate recovered becomes smaller.

Example Discussion:
If washing was excessive, part of the precipitate may have dissolved in the washing solution or fine precipitate particles may have been washed away.
As a result, the amount of precipitate recovered becomes smaller than the actual amount formed.
Therefore, washing should be performed only to the extent necessary and sufficient to remove impurities.

Relationship Between Precipitation Reactions and Qualitative Analysis

Precipitation reactions are commonly used in qualitative analysis to identify ions.
If a precipitate forms when a specific reagent is added, the corresponding ion may be present.
However, because other ions may form similar precipitates, the presence or absence of a precipitate alone is not sufficient for definitive identification.

Example Discussion:
A precipitation reaction provides a useful clue for estimating ions present in a sample.
However, because some ions produce precipitates with similar colors or solubilities, the target ion cannot be completely identified from precipitate formation alone.
Therefore, the precipitate color, solubility, confirmation reactions, and comparison with standard samples must be combined for judgment.

Relationship Between Precipitation Reactions and Quantitative Analysis

Precipitation reactions are also used in quantitative analyses such as gravimetric analysis and precipitation titration.
In gravimetric analysis, the target component is recovered as a precipitate and the amount of the component is determined from its mass.
In precipitation titration, precipitate formation is used to determine the endpoint and calculate the concentration of the target ion.

When precipitation reactions are used for quantitative analysis, it is important that the precipitate forms as completely as possible, that its composition is constant, and that losses of precipitate and contamination by impurities are minimized.

Example Discussion:
When a precipitation reaction is used for quantitative analysis, it is important that the target component precipitate as completely as possible.
If precipitation is incomplete, some of the target component remains in solution and the quantitative result becomes too low.
On the other hand, if impurities are included in the precipitate because of coprecipitation or insufficient washing, the precipitate mass becomes too large and the quantitative result is overestimated.

When the Result Can Be Considered Good

A good result in a precipitation reaction is indicated when a clear precipitate forms under the expected conditions and the color and solubility of the precipitate agree with the known reaction.
In addition, if the supernatant is clear and the precipitate can be sufficiently separated, the reaction can be considered to have proceeded relatively well.

Example Discussion:
Addition of the precipitating reagent produced a clear precipitate, and the color of the precipitate also agreed with the known reaction.
After standing, the precipitate collected at the bottom and the supernatant became almost clear.
From this, the reaction between the target ion and the precipitating-reagent ion is considered to have proceeded generally well, and the precipitate formed because the ionic product exceeded the solubility product.

Example Discussion When the Reaction Did Not Go Well

When a precipitation reaction does not go well, possible causes can be considered from results such as no precipitate, a small amount of precipitate, an unexpected color, redissolution of the precipitate, or loss of precipitate during filtration.
It is easier to organize the discussion by separately considering the ionic product, solubility product, pH, complex formation, common-ion effect, and washing and filtration operations.

Example Discussion:
One possible reason the amount of precipitate was smaller than expected is that the ionic product did not sufficiently exceed the solubility product.
If the concentration of the target ion in the sample was low or the amount of precipitating reagent added was insufficient, precipitation would remain incomplete.
In addition, if the metal ions formed complexes, the concentration of free metal ions would decrease and precipitate formation may have been suppressed.

How to Write Points for Improvement

In a discussion of a precipitation reaction, including points for improvement as well as sources of error makes the report easier to organize.
Improvements are easier to write when divided into methods for ensuring precipitate formation, methods for reducing precipitate loss, and methods for improving the accuracy of observations.

Methods for Stabilizing Precipitate Formation

  • Add an appropriate amount of precipitating reagent
  • Maintain the pH conditions specified in the laboratory manual
  • Stir the solution sufficiently
  • Allow sufficient time for observation after the reaction
  • Use the common-ion effect when necessary
  • Consider suppression of precipitation caused by complex formation

Methods for Reducing Precipitate Loss

  • Perform filtration or centrifugation carefully
  • Avoid losing fine precipitate particles
  • Use an appropriate type and amount of washing solution
  • Avoid both insufficient and excessive washing
  • Wash precipitate adhering to the apparatus into the collection vessel when necessary
  • Allow the precipitate to settle sufficiently before separation

Example of How to Write Points for Improvement:
To form the precipitate more reliably, it is necessary to add an appropriate amount of precipitating reagent and stir the solution sufficiently so that the ions mix uniformly.
In addition, because pH conditions affect precipitate formation, it is important to maintain the conditions specified in the laboratory manual.
During filtration and washing, precipitate loss can be reduced by avoiding loss or dissolution of the precipitate.

Difference Between a Superficial Discussion and a Good Discussion

In a discussion of a precipitation reaction, simply writing that “a precipitate formed” or “there was only a small amount of precipitate” results in a superficial discussion.
A persuasive discussion can be produced by relating the results to the solubility product, ionic product, pH, complex formation, and common-ion effect.

Superficial Discussion Good Discussion
A precipitate formed. Because addition of the precipitating reagent caused the ionic product of the target ion and precipitating-reagent ion to exceed the solubility product, the portion that could not remain dissolved precipitated as a solid.
No precipitate formed. One possible reason no precipitate formed is that the ionic product did not exceed the solubility product. Precipitation becomes less likely when the sample concentration or precipitating-reagent concentration is low or when complex formation lowers the concentration of free metal ions.
There was only a small amount of precipitate. Possible reasons the amount of precipitate was small include incomplete precipitation, partial dissolution of the precipitate, and loss of precipitate during filtration or washing. All of these factors reduce the amount of precipitate recovered.

Examples of Expressions That Can Be Used in Reports

The following expressions can be used when writing the results and discussion of precipitation reactions.
Adjust the necessary parts according to your own experimental results.

  • Adding the precipitating reagent caused the target ion and precipitating-reagent ion to react and form a sparingly soluble precipitate.
  • The precipitate can be explained as having formed because the ionic product exceeded the solubility product.
  • If the ionic product is smaller than the solubility product, precipitation is unlikely to occur.
  • One possible reason no precipitate formed is that the target-ion concentration or precipitating-reagent concentration was low.
  • The common-ion effect decreases the solubility of the precipitate and makes precipitation more favorable.
  • Changes in pH alter the concentration of precipitating ions and the form in which metal ions exist, affecting precipitate formation.
  • When complex formation lowers the concentration of free metal ions, precipitation is suppressed.
  • If an excess reagent forms a soluble complex, a precipitate that has already formed may redissolve.
  • The color of a precipitate provides a clue for estimating the chemical species, but it cannot be used alone for definitive identification.
  • When a precipitate is used quantitatively, the completeness of precipitation, coprecipitation, insufficient washing, and precipitate loss must be considered.

Points to Check When Discussing a Precipitation Reaction

Checking the following points before writing the report makes the discussion easier to write.

  • Have you recorded whether a precipitate formed?
  • Have you recorded the color and amount of the precipitate?
  • Have you explained the ions constituting the precipitate?
  • Have you discussed the relationship between the solubility product and ionic product?
  • Have you considered the reason no precipitate formed in terms of concentration and Ksp?
  • Have you considered the effect of pH conditions?
  • Can you explain the common-ion effect?
  • Have you considered suppression of precipitation by complex formation?
  • Have you explained why a precipitate may dissolve in excess reagent?
  • Have you avoided identifying the substance from precipitate color alone?
  • Have you considered errors caused by filtration, washing, and coprecipitation?
  • Do the points for improvement correspond to the sources of error?

Summary

A precipitation reaction is a reaction in which ions in solution react to form a sparingly soluble solid.
Whether a precipitate forms can be explained by the relationship between the ionic product in the solution and the solubility product.
When the ionic product exceeds the solubility product, the portion that cannot remain dissolved precipitates as a solid.

In discussing precipitation reactions, it is important to consider not only the presence or absence, color, and amount of precipitate but also ion concentrations, pH, the common-ion effect, complex formation, temperature, stirring, washing, and filtration operations.
Even if no precipitate forms, this does not necessarily mean that the target ion is absent, because the ionic product may simply have been insufficient.

In a report, do not simply write that “a precipitate formed,” but explain “why the precipitate formed” from the relationship between the solubility product and ionic product.
In addition, discussing the reasons for a small precipitate amount, sources of error, and points for improvement produces a persuasive discussion of the precipitation reaction.

Amazon.co.jpで関連する書籍や商品を見る
スポンサーリンク